Recognizing third-person limited and omniscient narrators, spotting clues that a narrator is unreliable, and thinking about how a story would change from another character's point of view.
Maine Learning Results learning standard: Reading 9 · limited, omniscient and unreliable narrators
How we explain it
Children can open this short lesson before they practice.
Third-person limited: he, she, they, inside one character’s mind.
Third-person omniscient: the narrator knows every character’s thoughts.
An unreliable narrator may be wrong or biased, so look for clues that don’t match what they say.
Example: A narrator uses he, she and they, and sees into only one character’s mind. What point of view is this? He, she and they mean third person. Only one mind means it is limited. Answer: third-person limited
Whose Story Is It? in Maine
In the Maine Learning Results, this is unit 5 of 12 in 8th grade English Language Arts, after Irony, Satire & Allusion and before Forms, Patterns & Visuals.
Gradelings describes a child's practice on this unit as Beginning, Approaching, Meeting or Exceeding (Four practice steps). That reflects practice, not a report-card mark: the teacher decides the mark.
A taste of this unit. In the app, questions change every time and get easier or harder to match your child.
Question 1
What is an unreliable narrator?
a narrator who speaks to the reader as you
a narrator who always knows everything
a narrator who may not tell the truth or may not understand events accurately
a narrator who never uses the word I
a narrator who may not tell the truth or may not understand events accurately
Hint: Readers have to look for clues to decide what is really happening.
Question 2
What can the reader NOT learn from this passage?
Outside the Doors
Amara stood outside the hospital doors, her backpack heavy on her shoulder. She wondered whether her grandmother would remember her today. Nurses hurried past, and she could not tell what any of them were thinking; their faces gave nothing away.
where Amara is standing
what the nurses are thinking
that Amara carries a backpack
that Amara is worried
what the nurses are thinking
Hint: A limited narrator cannot see into other minds.
Question 3
How does Kai see the fence?
The Fence
Kai watched the new neighbor's fence go up and saw it as a wall between them. Each board seemed to say, “Keep out.”
Across the yard, the neighbor hammered in the last nail. She felt proud. At last, her dog could play safely.
as a gift
as something to be proud of
as a wall that says to keep out
as a safe place for a dog
as a wall that says to keep out
Hint: Look at the first paragraph.
Question 4
Why does the narrator show both Kai's and the neighbor's thoughts?
The Fence
Kai watched the new neighbor's fence go up and saw it as a wall between them. Each board seemed to say, “Keep out.”
Across the yard, the neighbor hammered in the last nail. She felt proud. At last, her dog could play safely.
to hide the fence from the reader
to make the story shorter
to prove that Kai is wrong
to show that one event can mean different things to different people
to show that one event can mean different things to different people
Hint: The same fence means a wall to one and safety to the other.
Question 5
Whose thoughts does the reader learn?
Outside the Doors
Amara stood outside the hospital doors, her backpack heavy on her shoulder. She wondered whether her grandmother would remember her today. Nurses hurried past, and she could not tell what any of them were thinking; their faces gave nothing away.
everyone's
Amara's
the nurses'
her grandmother's
Amara's
Hint: She wondered…
Question 6
A narrator tells the story using he, she and they, and can see into only one character's mind. What point of view is this?
third-person omniscient
first person
second person
third-person limited
third-person limited
Hint: Third person uses he, she and they. Limited means we know the thoughts of only one character.